Сходознавство_№ 53-54.pdf

"$&(&)& $*,.,/"02$&20 46. 0. 7. 89(;$=8,>,

"0? ,"0@=",A 080.C; A "0)8 )890A"(

$*,.,/"02$&2,

53–54

!"% – 2011

!#$%')*%+, ), )'.0. 13%+,4 5!),4 7+9#;#.#. 9<,),>+!$9#$!

?A. B. D. E';A9F0,G, HBH J0'!K+; 16.06.2011 (N',#,0,O P 3)

Q,O,$+;R '%)!0#,'

).?.+., N',S. T. 1. U!#$WW$!

5%)!0X?R+! 0,O%G?Y:

Z. 7. BR\!\?+, ).?.+., 9.+.9.; 7. ]. _,+)!'%+0,, ).S.+., N',S.;

Z. _. _.\%+,0, ).?.+., 9.+.9.; 1. B. _.`!0,$, ).S.+.; Z. _. Q,O,$0,, ).?.+.;

1. Z. E?0#%+0,, 0.?.+., 9.+.9.; Z. a. U!$'?+!, 0.?.+., 9.+.9.;

Z. c. ZG+W$!, 0.?.+., 9.+.9.; 7. 1. Z#',d%+0,, ).?.+., 9.+.9.;

c. B. 5!)?$?O,$, 0.?.+., 9.+.9.; 1. a. 5;\!O0?+, ).S.+., N',S.;

E. U. e;d%+0,, ).S.+., N',S.; Z. Z. g!A'!R, ).S.+., 9.+.9.;

_. ]. iX%+0,, ).G.+., N',S.

(a0O!) '%)0,O%G?K >!#$%')*%+, 13%+,4 5!),4

7+9#;#.#. 9<,),>+!$9#$! ?A. B. D. E';A9F0,G, HBH J0'!K+;

24.03.2011)

1?)N,$?)!OF+;R 9%0'%#!' c. B. 5!)?$?O,$, 0.?.+., 9.+.9.

T?#%'!#.'+;R '%)!0#,' Z. i. Z',9

E,'%0#,' i. k. T%+G,

E,AN’4#%'+% A!0%#.$!++Y i. k. T%+G,

B)'%9! '%)!0X?K:

01001, E;K$-1, $.O. Q'.`%$9F0,G,, 4

7+9#;#.# 9<,),>+!$9#$! ?A. B. D. E';A9F0,G, HBH J0'!K+;

0. 205, #%O./S!09 278-76-52

a$?),X#$, N', )%'*!$+. '%W9#'!X?4

E7 P272 $?) 23.02.1998 '.

e-mail: skhodoznavstvo@gmail.com

1-! #! 4-! 9#,'?+0; ,\0O!);+0;: ]',$?+X?Y HG!'? eB5 (e;\%#9F0,G,

B$#,+,A+,G, '!R,+.) EH5. l,#, 1. ZNO!30! (E,O%0X?Y c,A.-U.>%4

?A. U.E. 5%'?<! (Z)%9!)).

?A. B. D. E';A9F0,G, HBH J0'!K+;, 2011

ISSN 1682-671X

!#%'() +. -.

"$%’'$)++' -/ 1-" 2)45+"6" 81-)++'

94' :% /;<5>"6" +) "9?

"#$&&' ()+ +-)$&&' #.)"#+)02 56' 7$8-9#&;+2 <=).8>;@+2 5.)-

A$=" #0>&+ (+=’'B$&+ B 0>#+)0<C >#=+).&&' #$ 50'6;&0>#C D>.>=0#-

&;+2 F0+&0>#>;@+2 H)J$&0B$K02. L (.)M"N 5&0= B$>&9=$&&' DFH 22

605.)" (+P$6" $@#"=&+ M9@$#" #.)"#+)0C, 5. &$K0' B&$85. &.

6"M. ()"#96+@, $ 8 70>#+ 7$8-9#&;+J+ 5.)A$=+#=+).&&'.

Q$ (+P$#@9 SS >#+60##' $6.>#"&$ '=6'6$ >+-+C +5&9 B &$8-

-06;M =05>#$6"N = .@+&+70P&+79 =05&+M.&&0 @)$2& U6"B;@+J+

FN+59, &$ 22 #.)"#+)02 &. -96+ &0'@"N B&$P&"N (+@6$50= @+)">&"N

@+($6"&. $6.>#"&$ +("&"6$>' = K.&#)0 9=$J" <=)+(.8>;@"N 5.)-

A$= P.).B >=+< ="&'#@+=+ ="J05&. >#)$#.J0P&. )+B#$M9=$&&'. Q$

#.)"#+)02 VJ"(#9 -9= ()+@6$5.&"8 F9.K;@"8 @$&$6, '@"8 B=’'B$=

F.).5B.7&. 7+). B W&508>;@"7 +@.$&+7 0 >#$= &$8=$A6"=0M+C

6$&@+C >=0#+="N @+79&0@$K08. Y.).B #.)"#+)0C $6.>#"&" ()+N+-

5"6" +>&+=&0 >9N+(9#&0 7$J0>#)$60 70A F.).5B.7&+7+)>;@"7

9B-.).AA'7 0 .)>;@+C B$#+@+C, = >9>05&08 Z.>+(+#$702 &07.K;-

@0 J.+6+J" B&$8M6" =.6"P.B&0 B$($>" &$\#".

Q$()"@0&K0 XIX >#+60##' >0+&0>#" >#$6" 5+7$J$#">' (05#)"7@"

D.6"@+-)"#$&02, '@$ (0>6' +@9($K02 = 1882 )+K0 VJ"(#9 )+BJ6'5$6$

$6.>#"&9 '@ &$8=$A6"=0M9 6$&@9 = >">#.70 >=+2N 7$8-9#&0N =+-

6+50&; &$ $)$->;@+79 FN+50. ] >=+C P.)J9, D.6"@+-)"#$&0' 7$6$

(+#).-9 = >+CB&"@9 56' B70K&.&&' >=+2N (+B"K08 &$ U6"B;@+79

FN+50, 9 #+79 P">60 8 56' -+)+#;-" B$ $6.>#"&9. ^$@"7" >+CB-

&"@$7" >#$6" >0+&0>#", '@0 &$7$J$6">' (.).@+&$#" D.6"@+-)"#$-

&0C = #+79, `+ = $6.>#"&0 >$7. B &"7" ="J05&0M. 7$#" >()$=9,

&0A 0B $)$->;@+C \.+5$6;&+-7+&$)N0P&+C =.)N0=@+C. ^$@, +5"&

0B 605.)0= >0+&0B79 (">$= ()+ #., `+ “<=).2 -959#; >()"'#" )+B="-

#@9 @)$2&", 9#=.)5A.&&C = &08 K"=060B$K02 #$ >#=+)'#; .\.@#"=-

&"8 B$N"># F9.K;@+J+ @$&$69” [Waines 1977, 226 ].

H>&+=+(+6+A&"@ (+60#"P&+J+ >0+&0B79 ^. a.)K6; &$(">$=

&$()"@0&K0 XIX >#+60##' @&"J9 “V=).8>;@$ 5.)A$=$. b+>=05 &+-

=0#&;+J+ )+B=’'B$&&' <=).8>;@+J+ ("#$&&'”, = '@08 &. (+B&$P"=

="B&$P.&+J+ 70>K' )+B#$M9=$&&' <=).8>;@+2 5.)A$=": “] 5$&"8

7+7.&# ' 7+A9 5$#" =>C 0&\+)7$K0C ()+ “B.76C +-0#+=$&9”,

4 !#%'() +. -.

@)07 +5&+J+ – 22 70>K.B&$N+5A.&&'”. ^. a.)K6; (">$= #$@+A, `+:

“]>0 &$)+5", 9 '@"N A"=9#; <=).2, – '=&0 P" B$7$>@+=$&0 $&#">.70-

#"”. ^+79 (05@).>6C=0=: “Q.N$8 &$7 &$5$59#; >9=.).&0#.# &$

'@08-&.-95; P$>#"&0 B.7&+2 @960, 5+>#$#&;+2 56' B$5+=+6.&&'

>()$=.56"="N ="7+J &$K02, ()+ 0&M. 7" (+5-$<7+ >$70” [a.)K6;

1898, 74 ].

L$ (’'#; )+@0= 5+ +(9-60@9=$&&' @&"J", 9 1893 )+K0 ^. a.)K6;

()+(+&9=$= (+J+6+=&. =+5+N).`.&&' <=).8>;@"N 50#.8, `+- <=).2

B6"6">' B @+)0&&"7" <=)+(.8>;@"7" &$)+5$7". D0& N+#0= B=.)&9-

#">' 5+ )"7>;@+J+ $(" 0B ()+N$&&'7 ()+ 5+(+7+J9 = K08 @$7($-

&02. a.)K6C 5$6" B)+B970#", `+ $($ &0@+6" &. ()"87. 8+J+

[c$@.) 2000, 129 ].

] >.)(&0 1897 )+@9 = U$B.60 (d=.8K$)0') &$ .)M+79 70A&$-

)+5&+79 B’2B50 >0+&0>#0= ^. a.)K6; =">#9("= 0B ()+J)$7+C >0+&0>#-

>;@+J+ )9N9. )+J)$7$ 70>#"6$ = >+-0: “1. F()"'&&' +)J$&0B+=$&+2,

7$>+=+2 @+6+&0B$K02 $6.>#"&". 2. )"5-$&&' ="B&$&+J+ =>07$

@)$2&$7" B$@+&&+J+ ()$=$ &$ @+6+&0B$K0C $6.>#"&". 3. F#=+).&-

&' (+>#08&+2 +)J$&0B$K02 56' +-’<5&$&&' =>0N <=).2= (05 ()$(+)+7

F0+&0B79” [Palestine. A Study of Jewish, Arab and British Policies

1947, 40,114 ].

L’2B5 9 U$B.60 ()"8&'= ()+J)$79 ^. a.)K6'; &$ &;+79 -96$

B$>&+=$&$ DFH, '@$ “+-’<5&9=$6$ =>0N <=).2=, '@0 ="B&$C#; ()+-

J)$79 >0+&0B79 0 >(6$P9C#; M.@.6;” [e">.6.= 1988, 19 ].

e+&J).> ()+J+6+>"= 7.#+C >0+&0B79 “>#=+).&&' = $6.>#"&0

B$@)0(6.&+J+ = (9-60P&+79 ()$=0 +>.).5@9 56' <=).8>;@+J+ &$)+-

59”. )+J)$7$ ()+J+6+M9=$6$: “F0+&0B7 ()$J&. >#=+)"#" 56' <=-

).8>;@+J+ &$)+59 ()$=++N+)+&&"8 ()"#96+@ 9 $6.>#"&0. b6'

5+>'J&.&&' K0<2 7.#" @+&J).> 7$= &$ 9=$B0: 1. b+K06;&"8 )+B="#+@

@+6+&0B$K02 $6.>#"&" <=).8>;@"7" N60-+)+-$7" #$ )+-0#&"@$7".

2. L$69P.&&' #$ BJ9)#+=$&0>#; 9>0N <=).2= 9 70>K.=0 #$ B$J$6;&0

>+CB" =05(+=05&+ 5+ B$@+&0= @+A&+2 @)$2&". 3. L70K&.&&' <=).8-

>;@+J+ &$K0+&$6;&+J+ (+P9##' #$ >$7+>=05+7+>#0. 4. +(.).5&0

B$N+5" 56' +5.)A$&&' BJ+5" 9)'59 &$ B508>&.&&' K06.8 >0+&0B79”

[a$>)$#'& 1999, 63 ].

0>6' .)M+J+ @+&J).>9 DFH )+BJ+)&96$ ()+($J$&59 05.8 >0+-

&0B79, ).B96;#$#+7 '@+2 >#$6+ B&$P&. B-06;M.&&' @06;@+>#0 8+J+

()"N"6;&"@0=. f$-"&" ==$A$6", `+ 095$2B7 7+A. )+B="=$#">'

#06;@" = $6.>#"&0, 597$CP" ()" K;+79, `+ $6.>#"&$ (+="&&$

/)12’31!''3 #%46#)48!:;')<) =6#!''3... 5

&$6.A$#" <=).'7 9 (+60#"P&+79 )+B970&&0, $ <=).8>;@$ 5.)A$=$

(+="&&$ -959=$#">' #06;@" &$ ).60J08&"N ()"&K"($N – “h).K W>-

)$.6; 56' &$)+59 WB)$26C =05(+=05&+ 5+ ^+)" WB)$26C” [Encyclo-

pedia of Zionizm and Israel 1971, 791 ].

] @&"B0 “V=).8>;@$ 5.)A$=$”, J+=+)'P" ()+ 7+A6"=. 70>K.

5.)A$=+#=+).&&', ^. a.)K6; BJ$59<, @)07 $6.>#"&", #$@+A 0 j)-

J.&#"&9. Q$ 597@9 a.)K6', &$5$&&' <=).'7 B.7.6; = j)J.&#"&0

-96+ - 59A. ="J05&"7 >$708 ).>(9-60K0 j)J.&#"&0. WB K;+J+ 7+A-

&$ B)+-"#" =">&+=+@, `+ +>#$#+P&+2 597@" ()+ #., 5. <=).2 (+="-

&&0 >#=+)"#" >=+C 5.)A$=9, 9 605.)0= >0+&0>#>;@+J+ )9N9 `. &.

>@6$6+>'. Q$ (.)M"N >0+&0>#>;@"N @+&J).>$N ()+(+&9=$6">' j)-

J.&#"&$, F"&$8>;@"8 (0=+>#)0=, e0(); >0+&0>#>;@0 605.)" ()+>"6"

9 (+)#9J$6;>;@+J+ 9)'59 5+B=+69 &$ (+>.6.&&' = Z+B$7-0@9, 9

-.6;J08>;@+J+ 9)'59 – = e+&J+. Q$ V >0+&0>#>;@+79 @+&J).>0 =

1901 )+K0 ^. a.)K6; +\0K08&+ (05#=.)5"=, `+ @0&K.=+C 7.#+C >0+-

&0>#0= < #06;@" $6.>#"&$ [Garaudy 1986, 153–154 ]. l0<2 (+B"K02

5+#)"79=$6$>' -06;M0>#; 605.)0= $&J608>;@"N <=).2= 5+ .)M+2

>=0#+=+2 =08&".

D">9=$&&' >0+&0>#>;@"7" 605.)$7" 05.2 5.)A$=+#=+).&&' =

$6.>#"&0 7$6+ 8 70A&$)+5&"8 $>(.@#; 05.' (+=.)&.&&' <=).2= &$

“B.76C ().5@0=” 9 $6.>#"&9 (+="&&$ -96$ B$K0@$="#" <=)+(.8-

>;@0 5.)A$=", `+ ().#.&59=$6" &$ B$N+(6.&&' @)$2&". H5&$@ >0+-

&0>#>;@"7 605.)$7 &.+-N05&+ -96+ (05=.>#" (05 KC 05.C #.+).-

#"P&9 -$B9. b6' #+J+ `+- 5+=.>#", `+ ()+#'J+7 #">'P+60#; <=).2

()$J&96" (+=.)&9#">' = $6.>#"&9 #$ >#=+)"#" #$7 <=).8>;@9

5.)A$=9, -96$ ="@+)">#$&$ #.+)0' ()+ >#$)+5$=&0>#; >0+&0B79. D0-

5+7"8 $&J608>;@"8 >0+&0># Q+)7$& U.&#="P (">$=: “F0+&0B7 #$-

@"8 A. 5$=&08, '@ 0 (+6+& <=).8>;@+J+ &$)+59 = P$>" )98&9=$&&'

N)$79 Q$=9N+5+&+>+)+7” [Bentwich 1946, 60, 115 ].

WB K"7 #=.)5A.&&'7 7+A&$ -96+ (+J+5"#">', '@-" 7+=$ 8M6$

()+ >#$)+5$=&0>#; >0+&0B79 ).60J08&+J+, B$>&+=$&+J+ &$ =0)0 9 ()"-

N05 “7.>02”, '@"8 (+=.)&. =>0N <=).2= 9 $6.>#"&9. m+ A >#+>9<#;-

>' 0>&9=$&&' B &$85$=&0M"N P$>0= >0+&0B79 '@ (+60#"P&+J+ )9N9, `+

>#$="= 7.#9 – ()$@#"P&+ B508>&"#" “).>#$=)$K0C WB)$26C” = $-

6.>#"&0, &. P.@$CP" ()"N+59 “7.>02”, #+ =$)#+ ="B&$#", `+ #$@+J+

>0+&0B79 `+&$87.&M. 5+ >.).5"&" XIX >#+60##' &. ="&"@$6+.

W5.' (+=.)&.&&' <=).2= 5+ $6.>#"&" 0 >#=+).&&' #$7 <=).8-

>;@+2 5.)A$=" &$6.A$6$ &. ^. a.)K6C #$ 0&M"7 605.)$7 I >0+&0>#-

Plik z chomika:

Inne pliki z tego folderu:

Inne foldery tego chomika: